J.I. Case 431 vs Renault Super 5-D (A)

10 material differences · fewer than 12

Tractor one

1960–1969

No measured PTO figure

Tractor two

1965–1967

No measured PTO figure

Which should you choose?

Read our verdict on the 431 and the Super 5-D (A) → It is generated from the rows below by a fixed, versioned rule set, and names the figure behind every call.

10 material differences · 4 fields identical or within 5%, which is not counted as material

J.I. Case 431 and Renault Super 5-D (A), field by field
Field	431	Super 5-D (A)	Gap
Engine
Engine power, claimed claimed	35.0 hp	34.5 hp	—
Engine declared	CASE G-188 D	RENAULT 709/30-31	differs
Displacement declared	3.09 L	2.26 L	+36% 431
Transmission
Top speed declared	12.4–21.7 mph · 20–35 km/h	15.5 mph · 25 km/h	differs
Hydraulics & hitch
Pump flow declared	8.5 gpm · 32.2 L/min	4.8 gpm · 18.0 L/min	+79% 431
Three-point lift at ends declared	—	3,880 lb · 1,760 kg	—
Rear PTO speeds declared	540 rpm	540 rpm	—
Weight & dimensions
Unladen weight declared	3,838 lb · 1,741 kg	3,494 lb · 1,585 kg	+10% 431
Wheelbase declared	85.0 in · 2,159 mm	73.2 in · 1,860 mm	+16% 431
Length declared	130.1 in · 3,305 mm	129.1 in · 3,280 mm	—
Width declared	79.6 in · 2,022 mm	61.8 in · 1,570 mm	+29% 431
Height declared	57.0 in · 1,448 mm	60.6 in · 1,540 mm	+6% Super 5-D (A)
Ground clearance declared	20.1 in · 510 mm	12.6 in · 320 mm	+59% 431
Turning radius, braked declared	7.9 ft · 2.41 m	9.5 ft · 2.90 m	+20% Super 5-D (A)
Fuel tank declared	40.8 qt · 38.6 L	42.3 qt · 40.0 L	—

Source

Source