Hürlimann XA 657 vs SAME Golden 65 Compatto
12 material differences
Which should you choose?
We will not advise between these two machines, because their power is not stated as the same quantity on both; the drive differs (2WD / 4WD; 4WD). The figures below are side by side so you can judge them yourself; each says whether it was measured, claimed or declared by its source.
Field by field
12 material differences · 4 fields identical or within 5%, which is not counted as material
| Field | XA 657 | Golden 65 Compatto | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Measured performance | |||
| PTO power, measured measured | — | 62.9 hp | — |
| Drawbar power, measured measured | — | 52.0 hp | — |
| Engine | |||
| Engine power, claimed claimed | 70.9 hp | — | — |
| Engine declared | Hürlimann 1000.4 W-5 | Same Deutz-Fahr Group 1000.3 AT1 | differs |
| Displacement declared | 4.00 L | 3.00 L | +33% XA 657 |
| Maximum torque declared | 170 lb·ft · 231 N·m | 167 lb·ft · 226.6 N·m | — |
| Transmission | |||
| Top speed declared | 24.9 mph · 40 km/h | 24.9 mph · 40 km/h | — |
| Clutch declared | Pedal operated dry single plate clutch | pedal-operated dry single-plate clutch | differs |
| Hydraulics & hitch | |||
| Hydraulic control declared | Load sensing | — | — |
| Pump flow declared | 9.0 gpm · 34.1 L/min | 9.1 gpm · 34.4 L/min | — |
| Pressure declared | 3,046 psi · 210 bar | 3,118 psi · 215 bar | — |
| Three-point lift at ends declared | — | 4,407 lb · 1,999 kg | — |
| Rear PTO speeds declared | 540/540E/1000 rpm | 540/1000 rpm | differs |
| Weight & dimensions | |||
| Unladen weight declared | 5,864 lb · 2,660 kg | 4,850 lb · 2,200 kg | +21% XA 657 |
| Maximum permissible mass declared | 11,023 lb · 5,000 kg | — | — |
| Wheelbase declared | 86.1 in · 2,186 mm | 75.8 in · 1,926 mm | +13% XA 657 |
| Length declared | 153.5 in · 3,900 mm | 135.1 in · 3,431 mm | +14% XA 657 |
| Width declared | 76.0 in · 1,930 mm | 50.8 in · 1,290 mm | +50% XA 657 |
| Height declared | 92.7 in · 2,355 mm | 83.1 in · 2,110 mm | +12% XA 657 |
| Ground clearance declared | 15.7 in · 400 mm | 9.1 in · 230 mm | +74% XA 657 |
| Turning radius, braked declared | 12.5 ft · 3.80 m | 13.1 ft · 4.00 m | +5% Golden 65 Compatto |
| Fuel tank declared | 95.1 qt · 90.0 L | 58.1 qt · 55.0 L | +64% XA 657 |
Hürlimann XA 657 sources
Source
- Source: Traktorenlexikon, “Hürlimann XA 657”
SAME Golden 65 Compatto sources
Source
- Source: OECD test report 1798, 1998
- Source: Traktorenlexikon, “SAME Golden 65 (DT) Compatto”